this is a straight foreward thread.

Master of Puppets or Rust In Peace? which album was more of a masterpiece?

I feel both albums are so great it merits having their titles being bolded on message boards, but I prefer Puppets.

Rust In Peace, poll?

Rust In Peace, poll?

what????????

Rip...........

what????????

You didn't have a poll up when I posted.

Master kicks ass, no matter what!

MOP without a doubt. The most influential Thrash Album of the 80's.

MOP without a doubt. The most influential Thrash Album of the 80's.

You can't really use that as an argument because RIP was released in the 90's.

Only Metallica album that is better than RIP is KEA. But barely... RIP>>MOP, IMO (not by greatness).

MOP by far.

I mean, Holy Wars almost makes up for it, but I don't like any of RIP's other songs...mostly because Dave Mustaine's voice is so annoying.

Only Metallica album that is better than RIP is KEA. But barely... RIP>>MOP, IMO (not by greatness).
RTL>>>RIP if you ask me.

I can't fucking decide!

ill song battle

Holy Wars < Battery
Hangar 18 = Master of Puppets
Take no Prisoners > The thing that should not be
Five Magics < Sanitarium
Poison was the cure < Disposable Heroes
Lecretia > Leper Messiah
Tornado of Souls <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<ORION
Dawn Patrol < Damage inc
Rust in Peace > [NO TRACK]

Master of Puppets wins, even when RIP got the bonus point.

They are still amazing fucking albums!! Can't get enough of them.

I can't fucking decide!

ill song battle

Holy Wars < Battery
Hangar 18 = Master of Puppets
Take no Prisoners > The thing that should not be
Five Magics < Sanitarium
Poison was the cure < Disposable Heroes
Lecretia > Leper Messiah
Tornado of Souls <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<ORION
Dawn Patrol < Damage inc
Rust in Peace > [NO TRACK]

Master of Puppets wins, even when RIP got the bonus point.

They are still amazing fucking albums!! Can't get enough of them.

Holy wars owns battary.

Holy wars owns battary.

according to who?

Do we need to make a Holy Wars v. Battery thread?

battary!!!!!!

Does it really matter?

err... sometimes...

Puppets

Holy Wars, Polaris, Hangar 18 vs MOP, Battery Damage Inc.

Yeah, Puppets.

Oh so very close. Both are in my top 5 albums of all time but MoP just about edges it... perhaps due to the fact that I watched the full thing live a few nights ago.

"Rust In Peace"

Why RIP owns MOP

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due >>> Battery
Hangar 18 >>> Master Of Puppets
Take No Prisoners >>> The Thing That Should Not Be
Five Magics <<< Sanitarium
The Poison Was The Cure <<< Disposable Heros
Lucretia <<< Lepper Messiah
Tornado Of Souls >>> Orion
Dawn Patrol <<< Damage Inc.
Rust In Peace... Polaris >>> Nothing
My Creation >>> Nothing

MOP: 4
RIP: 6

Why RIP owns MOP

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due >>> Battery
Hangar 18 >>> Master Of Puppets
Take No Prisoners >>> The Thing That Should Not Be
Five Magics <<< Sanitarium
The Poison Was The Cure <<< Disposable Heros
Lucretia <<< Lepper Messiah
Tornado Of Souls >>> Orion
Dawn Patrol <<< Damage Inc.
Rust In Peace... Polaris >>> Nothing
My Creation >>> Nothing

MOP: 4
RIP: 6 how DARE YOU RATE ANYTHING BETTER THEN ORION!!!

GOD HAVE MERCY ON YOUR SOUL!!!!!!

RIP Has My Creation?

I have been smoking or you are wrong.

how DARE YOU RATE ANYTHING BETTER THEN ORION!!!

GOD HAVE MERCY ON YOUR SOUL!!!!!!

RIP Has My Creation?

I have been smoking or you are wrong.

On remaster. It's not a demo or a dif mix, it's actually a song.

Looks like you've been smoking man.

i dont have remaster... I bought it in grade 5 (2003-2004)

All of my CD's are in EXCELLENT condition. I take care of them like they are the most fragile thing in the world.

Wish i'd been into metal in 5th grade :p

I was 10 years old when I first started listening to Metal.

ah.. I would tell you my story, but I know it would be a pointless post since nobody would respond to it.

You should get the remasters, they're t3h awesomeness. You can just download them off itunes.

You should get the remasters, they're t3h awesomeness. You can just download them off itunes. Yeah, I should start buying the remasters, but I bought all the good Megadeth albums that are not remasted and I am not going to spend more money on the same thing, but with extra demo tracks.. and re.. mastered...

*checks wallet*

What albums didja getz0rz already?

what I have:
RIP
Peace Sells
SFSGSW?
TSHF
Greatest Hits
Youthanasia
Countdown

none of which remasterd

Holy Wars...The Punishment Due < Battery
Hangar 18 < Master Of Puppets
Take No Prisoners > The Thing That Should Not Be
Five Magics < Sanitarium
The Poison Was The Cure < Disposable Heros
Lucretia > Lepper Messiah
Tornado Of Souls = Orion
Dawn Patrol < Damage Inc.
Rust in Peace...Polaris
My Creation

MOP 5
RIP 4

Biased. And RIP picks up 2 bonus points for extra tracks.

Definetly Rust.

Biased. And RIP picks up 2 bonus points for extra tracks.

how am I biased?

I already counted your two extra points, MOP still wins.

on a side note
Rust In Piece...Polaris < Blackened
My Creation < And Justice For All

Why RIP owns MOP

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due >>> Battery
Hangar 18 >>> Master Of Puppets
Take No Prisoners >>> The Thing That Should Not Be
Five Magics <<< Sanitarium
The Poison Was The Cure <<< Disposable Heros
Lucretia <<< Lepper Messiah
Tornado Of Souls >>> Orion
Dawn Patrol <<< Damage Inc.
Rust In Peace... Polaris >>> Nothing
My Creation >>> Nothing

MOP: 4
RIP: 6
LOL!.....no.
Battery>> Holy Wars.....
MOP>>> Hangar
Take No Prisioners>>The Thing that should not be
Sanitarium>>Five Magics
Disposable Heros>>>The Poison Was The Cure
Lucretia >> Lepper Messiah
Orion >>> (kicks the shit out of)Tornado Of Souls
Damage Inc. >>>(totally rapes) Dawn Patrol
Rust in piece, My creation =meh

MOP=6
RIP=4

Battery vs. Holy wars....... hard choice.

Holy Wars is the only Megadeth song I like.

I prefer Master of Puppets.

I dunno, I used to LOVE MoP, but for some reason I can't stand it now. Mabye I just heard it TOO much, or mabye I just realised how hideously overrated it is. I still love RTL and AJFA for some reason though...

Are you going to vote?

OMG 1lionhearted. Your sig!! YOUR FUCKING SIG!!

the link!!

That is hilarious. Kirk does suck. He really has to stop using his fucking wah pedal before I beat him with it.

Wow, butter insulting a member of Metallica.

^ true (butter's comment), but back in the day when that video was made Kirk fucking pwned.

Wow, butter insulting a member of Metallica. Let me tell you something.

Dave Mustaine is my fav guitarist in the world.

Kirk sucks.

Lars Sucks.

Jason Sucks. (uh oh. Letty is gonna rape me)

and James and Cliff are the only great people in Metallica.

Dave owns
Marty owns
Nick owns


david sucks.

Although, Metallica is my fav band because I LOVE melodies. See why I like Orion?

Megadeth needs more melodies!

Let me tell you something.

Dave Mustaine is my fav guitarist in the world.

Kirk sucks.

Lars Sucks.

Jason Sucks. (uh oh. Letty is gonna rape me)

and James and Cliff are the only great people in Metallica.

Dave owns
Marty owns
Nick owns


david sucks.

Although, Metallica is my fav band because I LOVE melodies. See why I like Orion?

Megadeth needs more melodies!

I`m not gonna rape you.
Think before you post stupid lines,Colonel.
The only person in Metallica who sucks is Lars.

Let me tell you something.

Dave Mustaine is my fav guitarist in the world.

Kirk sucks.

Lars Sucks.

Jason Sucks. (uh oh. Letty is gonna rape me)

and James and Cliff are the only great people in Metallica.

Dave owns
Marty owns
Nick owns


david sucks.

Although, Metallica is my fav band because I LOVE melodies. See why I like Orion?

Megadeth needs more melodies!

David Ellefson is a good bassist. Wish Dave would kick out the guys they have now and bring back Ellefson and Marty.

LOL! How the fuck does Ellefson suck?

Every bassist Metallica ever had, is awesome.

I dont know why Butter thinks otherwise, probably because he hasn't heard Flotsam & Jetsam..

David Ellefson is a good bassist. Wish Dave would kick out the guys they have now and bring back Ellefson and Marty. Than Megadeth would be my favorite thrash band.

Wish i'd been into metal in 5th grade :p

Yeah same here, I just sorta shrugged at my dad when he said "Hey look at me play this bass line, it's from an older band you wouldn't like* and he was right, I didn't like older bands, and I kept listening to my Good Charlotte. But then I was watching Vh1 a day later on a Led Zeppelin biography and it kept covering how they were like the greatest band ever so I got into Rock, I mean decent rock.

Master of Puppets Blows it outta the water, i Reckon Peace sells But Whos Buying has a close competition. Master of puppets as a album wins i like all the songs on it. its the only album from any band that i like all songs...o.o


Edit:Scratch that Master of Puppets AND Kill Em All are the 2 albums where i like all the songs..:p

I'm very late... but

Master of Puppets is the best thrash album (by influence and song-writting) from the 80s and 90s.

Both great albums but Master of Puppets can't lose to anything being compared to anything

I think RIP is better now..overlooked how better the riffs are IMO

Both great albums but Master of Puppets can't lose to anything being compared to anything Killers-Iron Maiden>>Mop and Aj4a. MOP bores me now, I like Disposable Heroes,Battery,and Damage Inc. Everything else on it is not enjoyable,yes, even Sanitarium.

Killers-Iron Maiden>>Mop and Aj4a. MOP bores me now, I like Disposable Heroes,Battery,and Damage Inc. Everything else on it is not enjoyable,yes, even Sanitarium.

MOP has horrible replay value, it just gets wirse every time you listin to it for a lot of people.

but try to remember the first time you listened to it, then compare it to RIP

I would say, based on the first time I listined to both albums












































RIP>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>MOP

RIP was definately not as good as MOP.. the only reason people get tired of MOP is because it was so good people kept listening to it

Holy Wars>>Mop (the whole album)

Holy Wars>>Mop (the whole album)

I listened to Holy Wars many times...and to tell you the truth...I wasn't extremely impressed with it. Sure, it's a good song, but it just doesn't do it for me. Then again, I dislike Mustaine's vocals. I just don't think they can stack up to the legendary MoP.

I listened to Holy Wars many times...and to tell you the truth...I wasn't extremely impressed with it. Sure, it's a good song, but it just doesn't do it for me. Then again, I dislike Mustaine's vocals. I just don't think they can stack up to the legendary MoP. Well said!

I would agree with B1ck, Holy wars is way better

I think the riffs are better and IMO Mustaine vocals are great

I do like Mustaine's voice too, I just think MOP is better.

Holy Wars and Hangar 18>Mop

Metallica>Megadeth

Not in talent.

In success

Megadeth riffs>>>>>>>>Metallica

Success as in more people like mainstream for Metallicas newer stuff

In that case, you will see so many more times the amount of musicians listing MoP as an influence rather than Rust In Peace.

Yes! Exactly!

MOP is better in greatness, no shit. But I think RIP has better music quality

Metallica>Megadeth

Megadeth > Metallica
Vocals: Metallica > Megadeth
Lead Guitars: Megadeth > Metallica
Rhythm Guitars: Metallica = Megadeth
Bass: Metallica > Megadeth
Drums: Megadeth > Metallica


This makes it look like at ie but hallows worked it out on x/10 basis on another thread and Megadeth won.

yeah, because when Hallows makes a chart it is set in stone.

descending opinions are frowned upon here at amf.

Megadeth > Metallica
Vocals: Metallica > Megadeth
Lead Guitars: Megadeth > Metallica
Rhythm Guitars: Metallica = Megadeth
Bass: Metallica > Megadeth
Drums: Megadeth > Metallica


This makes it look like at ie but hallows worked it out on x/10 basis on another thread and Megadeth won. I disagree with that I think Metallica has better Rythm guitars

Dave Mustaine owns hetfield

Mustaine plays lead

Mustaine plays lead

Do you even own any Megadeth albums? Look right inside the album, he plays lead and rhythm.

Im definatley going with MOP. Battery is one of my favorite songs ever

To tell yah the truth, Battery isn't one of my favorites .:eek:

Almost every live version of Battery> the album version.

It's close for me but "Master of Puppets", is the winner.

master of puppets without a doubt no weak spots on the album plus mustaines' voice doesnt do it for me

MOP is actually my least favorite of the Cliff Metallica albums. I would say first 4, but I like it more than AJFA. Rust In Peace is my favorite metal album, and one of my top albums of all time. It was also my first metal album. So, I choose Rust In Peace.

Rust In Peace for me.
But that's because I've always preferred Megadeth over Metallica.

Rust in peace,it maintains a quality.

got to be master guys!!!

This is tough, these are two of my favorite albums, but I have to say Master of Puppets.

RIP FTW no contest

Yeah RIP...

RIP deffinately (spelling)

master of teh pups

Master, all the way.

MOP as far as influence and impact is concerned, but RIP for....Everything else basically:)

Listening to a whole album in one sitting is sacred ritual for me. In which it needs to be well rounded it's greatness, needs to start strong and end strong.....
And Rust In Peace has the best 3 opening tracks i've ever heard.

Holy Wars
Hanger 18
Take No Prisoners

=]

CDs FTW mp3s are gay.

^^

If you have money.

i voted Rust In Peace

CDs FTW mp3s are gay.

right on, peyote!

neck and neck.
2 of my all time favorites.
puppets, by a nose.

^^

If you have money.

Well, that's true. I can't see myself missing out on all this killer metal if I couldn't afford to buy it. I do feel strongly that it is only right that I support
the bands that I dig though.

thats sick that MOP is winning...its a good album, but rust in peace is literally better in almost way..

Rust in Peace, just coz Master... has Sanitarium and Disposable Heroes which kinda fuck up the middle part of the album

CDs FTW mp3s are gay.

hell, you expect me to believe you lug around a discman everywhere you go? :rolleyes:

Master of Puppets is a landmark in metal history because:
1-its an awesome album
2-Cliff Burton's last album recorded
3-has influenced generations of musicians

Rust In peace is a great album because:
1-its Megadeth best album(IMO) and best line up
2-has really great solos and musical passages
3-its megadeth last completely thrash album

I think both have great merrits but master of puppets always raises the hairs on my neck when I hear it..its just a master piece!!

its the hardest poll ever!!
im a huge metallica and megadeth fan, both albums reflect the height of both bands but in different times.
id say master any day! as it was the original thrash album of the 80's. absolutely perfect!
great lyrics, riffs and amazing songs that will stand the test of time.

rip is an amazing album, and has megadeths best line up ever! but compared to the set list of puppets and burton! its puppets by far mang!!

hell, you expect me to believe you lug around a discman everywhere you go? :rolleyes:


I take one to the gym and I have a disk player in my CAR ....

As far as MOP goes I like Kill & Lighting better and Rust is still better than both of them.

I gotta sway toward Puppets. I am biased heavily for MetallicA but Megadeth has released some good stuff. Now if it were Peace Sells... VS. ReLoad I would vote Peace Sells...

Master of Puppets every day of the week and twice on sunday!!

Hmmmm Rust in Peace was Megadeth's fourth album, Master was only the third for Mr Hetlfield and co'. Plus there is quite a time difference between the two. RIP was 1990's and Master was in '84. I think Mustaine had really defined the whole thrashy sound to a fine point, which tended to be more precise and arguably advanced. Where as Master can be technical in the solo's but the Rhytm not so much. So i'de consider it to be an earlier form of thrash that, although enjoyable, can be played by a 13 year old.

Love 'em all =P

hell, you expect me to believe you lug around a discman everywhere you go? :rolleyes:

I do, it's not that difficult.

I do, it's not that difficult.

No shit ! Who has to LUG around a discman lol
We used to carry big ass Boom boxes around back when I was a kid. And some of them were BIG. Now some people are apparently not strong enough to LUG a discman around :rolleyes:

Master Of Puppets FTW!!!!!

Master of puppets, one of the greatest albums ever recorded!!

So, yeah, it's not a fair comparison, I mean, I guess it is, I'll take Rust in Peace over Master Of Puppets anyday, though I think Peace Sells and Killing is My Business are both better albums than any album Dave Mustaine has written for Metallica.

I'm gonna go with MOP

Hmmmm Rust in Peace was Megadeth's fourth album, Master was only the third for Mr Hetlfield and co'. Plus there is quite a time difference between the two. RIP was 1990's and Master was in '84. I think Mustaine had really defined the whole thrashy sound to a fine point, which tended to be more precise and arguably advanced. Where as Master can be technical in the solo's but the Rhytm not so much. So i'de consider it to be an earlier form of thrash that, although enjoyable, can be played by a 13 year old.

Love 'em all =P

MOP was 86. You already know my answer.

^Love your sig dude. Vic Rattlehead for prez

i honestly think RIP makes MOP look like shit....

MOP is a greally good album...but metallicas previous 2 were better..

even then RIP is about as close to perfect as you get...every riff is amazing, every solo is amazing, the drums are done perfectly...i love his vocals( although alot of people hate them)i really cannot fathom how MOP is winning by so much...kinda sickens me

I agree, the title song, holy wars, and hangar 18 are so much better than anything on MOP

Wanna know a secret?

I've never heard Rust in Peace. I thought Peace Sells was OK, but I never picked up RiP.

Shhhhhhhhh!

Wanna know a secret?

I've never heard Rust in Peace. I thought Peace Sells was OK, but I never picked up RiP.

Shhhhhhhhh!

are you being serious?

RIP is way different from peace sells...much more progressive...pick it up NOW

its fucking GODLY,

here

http://rapidshare.com/files/140514044/1990_-_M_-_R_I_P__Remastered_2004__forum.yump3.org_upload_by _Nike581.rar
pass= forum.yump3.org

Lulz, thanks dude but I'm on my home computer (dial-up) so no luck right now.


And yes, I'm dead serious, and ashamed. :(

Lulz, thanks dude but I'm on my home computer (dial-up) so no luck right now.


And yes, I'm dead serious, and ashamed. :(

damn,
its a life changing album...:)'

then youll understand my Mustaine Worship lol

whenever you hear it lemme know what you think of it

I wouldnt say either is a masterpiece but Rust In Piece is definetely my favourite of the two

Rust in Peace by miles and miles and miles.

its hard to deiced but i think i am going to have to go with master of puppets. now some people might say that i chose wrong but this is why i chose master of puppets. master of puppets just has that edge of pure heavy that rust in peace does not have not to say rust in peace isn't good but master of puppets hits it home with the heavy riffig.

its hard to deiced but i think i am going to have to go with master of puppets. now some people might say that i chose wrong but this is why i chose master of puppets. master of puppets just has that edge of pure heavy that rust in peace does not have not to say rust in peace isn't good but master of puppets hits it home with the heavy riffig.

Heavy riffing? Did you even listen to the album? Holy wars or five magics or Polaris ring a bell?

^ yes i fucking have i am a huge megadeth fan... master of puppets is only song on the record i like. i just have a different point of view on what makes a song metal.

dude...normally i dont talk absolutes when it comes to an opinion

but RIP IS better than master...what does MOP have on RIP?
NOTHING!! how can anybody listen to MOP then RIP and say MOP is better?

RIP shreds MOP to pieces.. lol

but sometimes simplicity is great.

^ That might be true. Repetition however, does not.

^ yes i fucking have i am a huge megadeth fan... master of puppets is only song on the record i like. i just have a different point of view on what makes a song metal.

So...your vote was based on the ONE song you liked? wtf!

oh shit the albums... in that case RIP is better but master of puppets the song still kills any other song in RIP, and i am done bye.

but sometimes simplicity is great.

i was not talking technically...
even though it is MUCH more technical

Holy Wars, Tornado of Souls, Hangar 18, Take No Prisoners, Lucretia> Master of Puppets

and the other 3 compare with it..

Master of Puppets every time.

Holy Wars is a bit of a masterpiece though.

Rust in Peace has the strongest 3 opening tracks i've ever heard on any album.

Holy wars - Master Piece
Hanger 18 - Master Piece
Take no prisinors - TAKE NO SHIT!!!

Rust in Peace easily. Master of Puppets wasn't even that good imo.

There's about 4 tracks on Master that I really like the rest if just meh. Rust In Peace though almost every song is as enjoyable to hear as the next time.

I prefer RIP.

Both albums rock, but I have to go with Puppets

You can't compare Master of Puppets to Rust in Peace.

You have to compare, if we're going chronologically by album:

Kill Em All - Killing Is My Business...And Business is Good!
Ride the Lightning - Peace Sells...But Who's Buying?
Master of Puppets - So Far, So Good...So What?
...And Justice for All - Rust in Peace

Black Album - Countdown to Extinction
Load - Youthanasia
Reload - Cryptic Writings

St. Anger - Risk

Death Magnetic - World Needs a Hero

If you wanted to go by time period, then you can't count all of the albums of either, and it would look something like this:

Master of Puppets - Either Killing is My Business or Peace Sells

And Justice - So Far, So Good...So What?

Black Album - Rust in Peace

Load - Youthanasia

Reload - Cryptic Writings
St. Anger - Either The World Needs a Hero or The System Has Failed

Death Magnetic - Either United Abominations, or whatever the album is that's coming out this coming January.

Oh OK :rolleyes:
We will be sure to check with you later to see if what we are comparing
meets your holy approval .

NOT

Master of Puppets

You can't compare Master of Puppets to Rust in Peace.

You have to compare, if we're going chronologically by album:

Kill Em All - Killing Is My Business...And Business is Good!
Ride the Lightning - Peace Sells...But Who's Buying?
Master of Puppets - So Far, So Good...So What?
...And Justice for All - Rust in Peace

Black Album - Countdown to Extinction
Load - Youthanasia
Reload - Cryptic Writings

St. Anger - Risk

Death Magnetic - World Needs a Hero

If you wanted to go by time period, then you can't count all of the albums of either, and it would look something like this:

Master of Puppets - Either Killing is My Business or Peace Sells

And Justice - So Far, So Good...So What?

Black Album - Rust in Peace

Load - Youthanasia

Reload - Cryptic Writings
St. Anger - Either The World Needs a Hero or The System Has Failed

Death Magnetic - Either United Abominations, or whatever the album is that's coming out this coming January.

Oh, ok and then well compare garage inc. with Md.45.
Dude Rust in peace pwns EVERYTHING metallifail has done... Master of Puppets gets boring after 15 minutes. Plus for some strange reason the vocals bore the hell out of me.

You can't compare Master of Puppets to Rust in Peace.

You have to compare, if we're going chronologically by album:

Kill Em All - Killing Is My Business...And Business is Good!
Ride the Lightning - Peace Sells...But Who's Buying?
Master of Puppets - So Far, So Good...So What?
...And Justice for All - Rust in Peace

Black Album - Countdown to Extinction
Load - Youthanasia
Reload - Cryptic Writings

St. Anger - Risk

Death Magnetic - World Needs a Hero

If you wanted to go by time period, then you can't count all of the albums of either, and it would look something like this:

Master of Puppets - Either Killing is My Business or Peace Sells

And Justice - So Far, So Good...So What?

Black Album - Rust in Peace

Load - Youthanasia

Reload - Cryptic Writings
St. Anger - Either The World Needs a Hero or The System Has Failed

Death Magnetic - Either United Abominations, or whatever the album is that's coming out this coming January.

You're an idiot.

dont get me wrong, i like metallica, they got me into metal in the first place...

but looking back at them the only great album they put out is kill em all and ride the lightning...the next 2 (and somewhat BA) are good but not amazing..

It makes me sad to see that Master Of Puppets has majority of the votes. Rust in Peace is far superior.

It makes me sad to see that Master Of Puppets has majority of the votes. Rust in Peace is far superior.

i agree...MOP has nothing on rip aside from POSSIBLY vocals

I think RIP, because of marty was there..

MOP by a couple miles. It isn't even close

MOP by a couple miles. It isn't even close

explain why,

what about mop is better than RIP

BECAUSE METALLICA IS THE BEST THRASH BAND EVER, RIGHT??

Wrong. Megadeth beats metallica in all areas. See that? metallica doesn't even deserve to be capitalized.

BECAUSE METALLICA IS THE BEST THRASH BAND EVER, RIGHT??

Wrong. Megadeth beats metallica in all areas. See that? metallica doesn't even deserve to be capitalized.

You're wrong man METALLICA deserve to be capitalized but only its followed by SHIT

Ha, absolutely.

To all you Megadeth-is-better-than-Metallica people, I have two words: Crush em!

I have one word for you. Megadeth is better then metallica.

I have one word for you. Megadeth is better then metallica.

Oh, to be an educated man among a pack of near-illiterates! :(

I like both but probably MOP

To all you Megadeth-is-better-than-Metallica people, I have two words: Crush em!

umm, according to your "theory"
Kill Em All-Killing is my Business
Ride the Lightning-Peace Sells
Master of Puppets-So Far So Good So What
...And Justice for All-Rust in Peace
Black Album-Countdown to Extinction
Load-Youthanasia
Reload-Cryptic Writings
St Anger-Risk

lol dissing a song off risk when metallica put out st anger?
seriously st anger was below shit, not one listenable song

Oh, to be an educated man among a pack of near-illiterates! :(

(sigh) I obviously knew that what I said was more then one word. Do I appear to be an unintelligent ape? So far, everyone i've met that prefers Megadeth over Metallica has been some of the smartest people I know. Not saying all Metallica fans are dumb, but majority of the ones i've met/know are pretty stupid.

(sigh) I obviously knew that what I said was more then one word. Do I appear to be an unintelligent ape? So far, everyone i've met that prefers Megadeth over Metallica has been some of the smartest people I know. Not saying all Metallica fans are dumb, but majority of the ones i've met/know are pretty stupid.

I really don't believe there is any correlation between the preference of Megadeth over Metallica and intelligence levels. But if you want to do the research and publish an article in a reputable peer-reviewed journal it would be a most interesting read. :D

i can not stress enough how much better Megadeth is than Metallica. Risk and cryptic writings sucked. but everything from And Justice for All to Death Magnetic have sucked. so bassicaly RIP>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>MOP

To all you Megadeth-is-better-than-Metallica people, I have two words: Crush em!

And I have two words for you motherfucker ST. ANGER!

I really don't believe there is any correlation between the preference of Megadeth over Metallica and intelligence levels. But if you want to do the research and publish an article in a reputable peer-reviewed journal it would be a most interesting read. :D

I know. I'm just saying that the people I know that like Metallica more compared to the people that like Megadeth are usually idiots.

I know. I'm just saying that the people I know that like Metallica more compared to the people that like Megadeth are usually idiots.

What about people that like them both about the same? I love the first 5 Megadeth albums and the first 4 Metallica albums plus the last one. So to me they are pretty equal.

i gotta agree with palefolklore...
not in every case, but in many cases the people that prefer metallica over megadeth have..
shitty musical taste?(in my opinion i guess)

Same here. Most of the people I know who are "hardcore" Metallica fans are either rednecks or arrogant arseholes